INTRODUCTION
This worksheet has been compiled from the advice of a number of journals and publications. The aim of the worksheet is to give less-experienced peer reviewers a concrete workflow of questions and tasks to follow when they first peer-review. Please note that this is a suggested framework for reviewers to follow. Depending on the journal or subject field, some lements may be lacking. Users should adapt the worksheet to suit their needs, their personal review style, and the journal’s guidelines.
EVERY PEER-REVIEW PROCESS SHOULD AIM TO (HAMES, 2008):