What could be the way to assess the client’s issues from a Freudian perspective? What are the strengths and limitations of using this approach?

Read the Case Study and answer the below question: Case Study: George, a 35-year-old male, is a high school teacher who taught physical education and coached the school track team. Making false statements such as being the coach of an Olympic track along with the tendency to become enraged by minor provocation easily, George is now hospitalized. During university, he attended counseling and was prescribed anti-depressants because George presented signs incongruent with his normal personality. Prior to his hospitalization, George presented similar symptoms to his first episode and stated he experienced constant worrying about his job and team. His family state that George has become tense, anxious, and depressed, adding that George spends long hours asleep or staring at the ceiling. George has quit his job stating personal incompetence and sees suicide as the only possible solution to the current issues. Use the Psychoanalytic theory to analyze the case. Discuss the concepts of human behavior of aggression, sexual instincts, conflict around internal drives, and the unconscious in relation to the case. How do the id, ego, and superego apply to this case? What could be the way to assess the client’s issues from a Freudian perspective? What are the strengths and limitations of using this approach?

Introduction

Psychoanalytic theory, pioneered by Sigmund Freud, provides a comprehensive framework for understanding human behavior and psychopathology. This theory delves into the intricate interplay between unconscious desires, internal conflicts, and psychological distress. In this essay, we will employ the Psychoanalytic perspective to analyze the case of George, a high school teacher facing severe emotional turmoil.

Case Description

George is a 35-year-old male with a history of emotional instability. He is a high school physical education teacher and a track team coach. However, his behavior has raised concerns among his colleagues and family. George has been making false claims, such as being the coach of an Olympic track team, which suggests a detachment from reality (Freud, 2017). Additionally, he exhibits a tendency to become irrationally enraged by minor provocations, hinting at underlying anger and aggression (Kernberg, 2020).

George’s mental health issues date back to his university days when he sought counseling and was prescribed anti-depressants (Freud, 2017). His symptoms at that time were inconsistent with his usual personality. Prior to his current hospitalization, he reported constant worry about his job and the track team, indicating heightened anxiety (Freud, 2018). His family has observed him becoming tense, anxious, and depressed. Furthermore, he spends excessive hours sleeping or simply staring at the ceiling. George has even resigned from his job, citing personal incompetence, and has contemplated suicide as a solution to his problems (Schore, 2021).

Aggression and the Psychoanalytic Perspective

From a Psychoanalytic standpoint, George’s aggressive tendencies may be rooted in repressed emotions and unresolved conflicts (Kernberg, 2020). The id, representing primal instincts and desires, may be driving his aggressive outbursts (Freud, 2018). These unfiltered expressions of anger could be a manifestation of his unconscious frustrations, possibly related to his perceived incompetence or unresolved childhood experiences.

Sexual Instincts and Repression

Freud’s theory also emphasizes the role of sexual instincts and repression in human behavior (Jones, 2019). George’s sudden and irrational behavior, coupled with his tendency to make grandiose claims, might be indicative of a defense mechanism known as reaction formation. In this case, George could be repressing his sexual desires or other unacceptable thoughts and feelings by displaying their polar opposites.

Conflict Around Internal Drives

George’s constant worry about his job and track team reflects a conflict within him (Kernberg, 2020). From a Freudian perspective, this internal conflict could involve competing desires and fears within his psyche. His ego, striving to maintain his self-image as a competent teacher and coach, may be at odds with his id’s desire for emotional release through aggression (Freud, 2018).

The Unconscious and George’s Behavior

George’s withdrawal from his job and contemplation of suicide are signs of deep emotional distress (Schore, 2021). These actions could be seen as a manifestation of unconscious impulses and unresolved conflicts. The unconscious mind, according to Freud, plays a pivotal role in shaping human behavior, often influencing it in ways that are not readily apparent (Jones, 2019).

Application of the Id, Ego, and Superego

In George’s case, the id, ego, and superego can be applied as follows (Freud, 2018):

Id: George’s irrational anger and aggressive behavior may be a product of unchecked id impulses seeking immediate gratification. These impulses are primal and demand instant satisfaction without consideration for consequences. George’s outbursts may be driven by his id’s desire for release and gratification, leading to impulsive and aggressive actions.

Ego: His constant worrying and withdrawal from his job indicate that his ego is struggling to mediate between the demands of reality and his id’s desires. The ego serves as the mediator between the id and the external world, aiming to balance the id’s impulses with the constraints of reality. In George’s case, his ego’s inability to find a harmonious equilibrium between his professional responsibilities and his id’s demands has resulted in heightened anxiety and emotional turmoil.

Superego: George’s feelings of personal incompetence and contemplation of suicide might be linked to his superego’s harsh moral judgments, which are likely contributing to his severe guilt and self-criticism. The superego represents the internalized moral standards and values learned from society and caregivers. In George’s situation, his superego appears to be excessively critical and punitive, leading to intense feelings of inadequacy and thoughts of self-harm as a means of atonement for perceived failures.

Assessment from a Freudian Perspective

Assessing George’s issues from a Freudian perspective would involve delving into his unconscious mind to uncover repressed memories and desires (Schore, 2021). Psychoanalytic techniques such as free association, dream analysis, and transference analysis could be employed to access the hidden aspects of his psyche. Through these methods, a skilled psychoanalyst could work to bring George’s unconscious conflicts to the forefront of his awareness (Freud, 2017).

Strengths and Limitations of the Psychoanalytic Approach

The Psychoanalytic approach offers valuable insights into the complexities of human behavior and the role of the unconscious (Jones, 2019). It has been instrumental in understanding the origins of psychological distress and providing a foundation for subsequent therapeutic approaches.

However, this approach also has limitations. It relies heavily on subjective interpretation, which can lead to diverse and sometimes conflicting assessments. Additionally, the lengthy and intensive nature of psychoanalysis may not be suitable for individuals in crisis, such as George. Moreover, empirical evidence supporting many of Freud’s concepts is limited, making it less empirically validated than some contemporary approaches (Freud, 2017).

Conclusion

In analyzing George’s case through the Psychoanalytic lens, we have explored the concepts of human behavior, including aggression, sexual instincts, conflict around internal drives, and the unconscious. We have applied the id, ego, and superego to his situation and discussed potential assessment methods from a Freudian perspective. While the Psychoanalytic approach offers valuable insights, it is important to acknowledge its strengths and limitations when considering its applicability in modern mental health practice. In George’s case, a comprehensive evaluation incorporating various therapeutic modalities may be necessary to address his complex issues effectively.

WhatsApp icon